How to Choose the Best Deck Railing: Composite vs. Aluminum

Composite vs. Aluminum: How to Select the Ideal Deck Railing

Choosing the best deck railing is as important as selecting the deck itself. The materials you choose will influence the look of your outdoor space and also its safety and maintenance needs. With years of experience serving homeowners across New Jersey and Pennsylvania, Deck Guardian has put together this guide to help you navigate the choices between composite and aluminum railings—two of the most popular materials on the market.

Aluminum deck railings, known for their robustness and longevity, offer a sleek, modern look that withstands the elements with minimal upkeep. On the other hand, composite deck railings provide a cost-effective solution with a variety of style options that mimic the classic appearance of wood without extensive maintenance and upkeep.

In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both aluminum and composite deck railings to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your home’s style, your personal preferences, and New Jersey’s weather challenges.

Overview of Deck Railing Materials

The best deck railing will be one that adds safety, looks great, fits your budget, and stands up to the elements. So, what is the difference between composite and aluminum railings? Here is what sets them apart:

Composite Deck Railing

Composite deck railing is made from a mixture of plastic and wood fibers. This combination helps make the railings strong and durable while also giving them a look that resembles real wood. Composite railings are popular because they do not need much maintenance. Unlike wood, you do not have to paint or stain them regularly to keep them looking nice. They are also resistant to rotting, warping, or damage by insects.

Composite railings are a good choice if you want a beautiful deck without a lot of extra work to take care of it. They come in many colors and styles, so you can easily find something that matches your home’s design.

Aluminum Deck Railing

Aluminum deck railing is made from a lightweight metal known for its strength and durability. One of the main advantages of aluminum railings is that they are very strong and can last a long time without rusting or breaking down, even in harsh weather conditions. They are also easy to take care of, usually needing only occasional cleaning with soap and water.

Aluminum railings come in various finishes and colors, but the choices are not as varied as with composite railings. These railings are a great option if you’re looking for something sturdy and low-maintenance. They can be a bit more expensive than other types of railings, but their longevity and minimal upkeep often make them worth the extra cost.

Pros and Cons of Composite Deck Railing

Composite deck railings are a popular option because of their balance of cost-effectiveness, sleek appearance, versatility, and ease of maintenance. Yet, like all materials, they come with their own set of strengths and weaknesses. Here, we will explore the pros and cons of composite deck railings to help you make an informed decision:

Pros of Composite Railings:

1. Cost-Effectiveness: Generally, composite railings offer a more economical initial cost compared to aluminum railings. They provide a balance between quality and affordability, which makes them a popular choice for many homeowners.
2. Aesthetic Flexibility: Composite deck railings come in a wide variety of colors and finishes, including options that mimic the look and feel of natural wood. This versatility makes it easier to match or complement your home’s exterior and decking.
3. Low Maintenance: Unlike wood, composite materials do not require staining, painting, or sealing. They are designed to resist warping, staining, fading, and mold, which reduces the need for regular upkeep.

Cons of Composite Railings:

1. Lower Structural Strength: While highly durable, composites may not offer the same level of rigidity as aluminum railings and can be more susceptible to flexing, especially in long spans.
2. Thermal Expansion: Composite materials can expand and contract with temperature changes, which may require additional considerations during installation to allow for movement.
3. Fading and Staining: Although modern composites are highly resistant to fading and staining, they can still be affected over many years of exposure to the elements, and some lower-quality composites may show signs of wear sooner.

Pros and Cons of Aluminum Deck Railing

Many homeowners appreciate aluminum deck railings for its structural integrity and minimal maintenance requirements. However, to make the best decision on whether it’s right for your next deck project, it’s important to consider both the advantages and drawbacks of aluminum deck railings:

Pros of Aluminum Railings:

1. Durability and Lifespan: Aluminum railings are known for their exceptional durability. They do not rust, corrode, or degrade from exposure to the weather, making them ideal for harsh climates and coastal areas.
2. Low Maintenance: Aluminum requires very little maintenance. It typically has a powder-coated finish that lasts for years without the need for repainting. Occasional cleaning with mild soap and water is usually all that’s needed.
3. Lightweight and Strong: Aluminum deck railing is lightweight yet strong, which makes it easy to work with and install. Its strength ensures a secure, sturdy railing system that can handle impacts and heavy loads.

Cons of Aluminum Railings:

1. Higher Cost: Generally, aluminum railings are more expensive than composite options, both in terms of initial material costs and sometimes installation costs, due to their metal nature.
2. Limited Style Options: While available in several basic colors and finishes, aluminum does not offer the same range of aesthetic options as composites, particularly those that mimic other materials like wood.
3. Conductivity: Aluminum is a conductor of heat and cold, which means railings can become very hot in summer or cold in winter, potentially making them uncomfortable to touch in extreme temperatures.

Composite Vs. Aluminum Railings: Final Recommendations

When it comes to selecting the best deck railing for your home, both composite and aluminum railings offer benefits that cater to different needs and tastes. Here at Deck Guardian, we recommend taking a holistic approach to your decision. You must consider several key aspects when making your final decision on the best deck railing materials, such as:

Your Home’s Architectural Style

Your house’s style should guide your choice of deck railing. Composite railings, with their variety of textures and colors, can complement traditional homes by offering a classic look that mimics wood without maintenance. Aluminum railings, with their sleek and minimalist design, are ideal for modern homes, providing a contemporary feel that highlights clean lines.

Your Budget

While initial costs are an important consideration, think about long-term savings too. Aluminum railings, though potentially more costly upfront, often require less maintenance over their lifespan, which might save money in the long run. Composite railings, typically more affordable initially, offer a great balance between cost and performance, making them a budget-friendly option for many homeowners.

Your Personal Preferences and Lifestyle Needs

If you frequently use your deck and prefer a comfortable, touch-friendly material during both hot and cold weather, composite might be more suitable as it does not conduct temperature as much as aluminum. But, if you prioritize strength and longevity to withstand physical impacts or heavy use, aluminum could be the better choice.

Deck Guardian is committed to helping homeowners in New Jersey and Pennsylvania find the perfect deck railing materials that fit their lifestyle, budget, and personal preferences.

RELATED BLOG — A Helpful Guide to Choosing the Best Deck Railings

Let Us Design Your Ideal Deck with the Perfect Railing

Both composite and aluminum railings offer unique benefits and come with a few drawbacks. Which material is best for you will depend on your specific needs, preferences, budget, and the architectural style of your home. Whether you choose the strong elegance of aluminum or the versatile beauty of composite, both materials will transform your deck into a long-lasting extension of your home.

For further help and to explore more about our deck railing options, feel free to reach out or visit our showroom. Let Deck Guardian help you make a choice that you will be proud of. Whether you’re building a brand new deck, adding a porch, or tackling a deck resurfacing project, Deck Guardian is your go-to New Jersey deck builder. Contact us today!